"Piper" is Marnie's last name from her father. Cromwell is Aggie's last name and Gwen's maiden name. First off, yeah Kimberly J. Brown wasn't in the movie. What the heck was Disney thinking?! Obviously they weren't. And I agree with everyone else here. Kimberly J. Brown played Marnie with amazing talent. She brought life to the character that obviously many people loved. She was tough, brave, and not too worried about breaking the rules when she needs to (like in the second movie with the portal.) Sara Paxton played Marnje as some stupid, dimwitted, scaredy cat. What a disappointment. If the issue with Kimberly J. Brown was just scheduling issues, then postpone the making of the movie. It has a crappy plot anyways, and we could've all been spared instead of wasting our time that we'll never get back. Thanks Disney for making yet another terrible movie. The first three were good. The fourth one would probably have been better if there weren't so many things and characters taken out and the special effects weren't so cheesy. Disney, if you must insist on making sequels and crap, here's a couple tips: keep the original characters, stop using crappy special effects, write a better storyline, or just don't make them. I would love to see more Halloweentown movies, as long as the main characters are still played by the originals!!!! -.-

This movie was good,but there were some things I didn't like 1. How they changed it to Sarah Paxton instead of Kimberly j.brown because Kimberly has a shape to her but, well Sarah doesn't its just that plain and simple it looked like she lost a TON of weight. Also she looked nothing like Kimberly.2 some of the costumes were a bit cheesy.3. some of the effects were cheesy too,they could've done better. once i found out Kimberly wasn't going too be on Holloweentown i knew right away this was probably going to be very interesting and not in a good way Kimberly just added that spunk to the movie and it was a lost to not have her there.

This movie was just horrible, and I hope that they make another one to redeem themselves.Hopefully this time they will have the right Marnie, because if they don't it will probably be worse than return to halloweentown!Not only is the acting just horrible, the characters are horrible as well! I mean they don't have Sophie, or their grandma. Another thing is that the whole plot doesn't make any sense. Than they didn't even know who the Cromwells were. The sad thing is that I cant even remember half of the movie. The only thing I remember is her going to the college. Other than that I cant remember anything that had happened in the movie. I cant remember who the bad person was and what they wanted!

Return to Halloweentown was a lot better than the other three because in the first one yes she did use magic without even thinking about it but in this one she is at Witch U to learn to control her powers and make them more powerful so if she used them without thinking it would be a waste of the schools time meaning the movie would be pointless. Seeing that she didn't use her powers the instant she had a stupid Idea meant that she was learning to control them not that she was being a wimp. like they say in all the movies... with true power comes true responsibility and I think they made this Halloweentown very well thank you very much. In addition to that You DON'T need Linkberly J Brown to make the movie... yes it would have been nicer but that is like saying if Paula Abdul left American Idol than it would be ruined... but if Paula left American Idol then it wouldn't be horrible granted it would be different but If you watched American Idol for the singing the judges don't matter. So I give Return to halloweentown two thumbs up!