A Deutsche Styria Film. English version made by The American Dubbing Co. for Carlton Films. U.S. release through Distributors Corporation of America: 1958. West German release through Gloria: 23 October 1952 (sic). 92 minutes. German title: ALRAUNE. SYNOPSIS: An iconoclastic professor's mysterious but highly attractive daughter has no less than four young men in a spin. NOTES: Fifth remake of the 1911 Hans Heinz Ewers novel. There were three silent versions of which the most famous is the 1928 release with Brigitte Helm and Paul Wegener. Miss Helm starred again in the 1930 remake, this time oppposite Albert Bassermann and a somewhat second-string cast rather stagily directed by Richard Oswald (doubtless hampered by the demands of the sound engineer). 11952 seemed an opportunistic time for a full-scale remake, using a top-of-the-range budget and an impressive cast led by Erich von Stroheim (making his first film appearance after his Hollywood comeback role in Sunset Boulevard), Hildegard Knef (then at the height of her fame-she starred in no less than seven films in 1952), and Karlheinz Bohm (later to play the title role in Peeping Tom).COMMENT: Although this film is only at present available in its English-dubbed version, one must admit that the dubbing, for once, is exceptionally good. The principal dubbers even make laudable attempts to imitate both Knef's and Von Stroheim's voices and their methods of delivery. It's also pleasing that Fraulein Knef's songs have been left to speak for themselves in their original German and that Werner Heymann's most appropriate background music has been retained. Rabenalt is not usually thought of as a classy director, but, helped by the atmospheric sets and photography, he has done wonders here. Extremely fast-clipped film editing keeps the plot moving at a breakneck pace for almost every second of its 92 minutes.

The title refers to the German word for Mandrake root. A disturbing and noir-like horror movie that viewers will either love or hate, it has a queasy quality with elements of camp that will either annoy or delight.Charismatic actor and director Erich von Stroheim, who held his own in Sunset Boulevard, doesn't disappoint here. Karl Boehm, the wide-eyed, eerily handsome actor who rose to stardom in the British cult horror classic Peeping Tom, is also very watchable.Context is everything. This is an intriguing horror film that will reward a second viewing.

Unnatural: Fruit of Evil/Alraune/Mandragore - I have not seen 1918, nor the 1928 or the 1930 versions of this film, so I have nothing to compare this 1952 with.A scientist has taken the 'seed' of murderer and impregnated a prostitute by artificial insemination. The scientist thought the results would make for a more interesting study from bad people, because good people are so boring - as he explains.It seems that artificial insemination sparked fears and ideas in people of the early 1900s... but a fairly interesting film came from it. There are better sci-fi horror films of the 1950s but this one is still worth a one time watch.6.5/10

I had watched the best-regarded (if still rare) 1928 Silent version of this much-filmed German melodrama with Sci-Fi undertones during a previous Halloween challenge; while I recall precious little of that one at this juncture, having re-read my review of it, I know the remake features a different conclusion – as well as a different method of creation for the titular figure (the more realistic one of artificial insemination here instead of her emanating from the mandrake root, though the plant remains much in evidence throughout even now). Still, offhand, I would say that both films are equally effective – with the lead roles being especially well-filled: Erich von Stroheim and Hildegarde Knef (at her loveliest) in this adaptation replacing Paul Wegener and Brigitte Helm respectively in the earlier movie; leading the supporting cast, however, is Karl Boehm (who would excel in his later genre role in the British-made PEEPING TOM [1959]). As I said, events are not exactly fantastic – indeed, leaning more towards romance in the vein of two other much-filmed and horror-tinged classics, namely "The Picture Of Dorian Gray" and "Trilby" (often filmed as SVENGALI and whose 1954 British version, incidentally, also had Knef as its leading lady!) – but, then, Stroheim does keep a caged ape (which comes to no use other than as an added bizarre touch!) in his laboratory and, in any case, the result is no less stylish for that; all in all, this is ample proof that the Germans did not lose their touch for the Expressionistic with the advent of WWII! The premise, too, of a femme fatale turning the heads of several men, all of whom know one another and naturally fall out over her, is interesting for its distinct film noir trappings – in this case, extending to the rethought doom-laden climax that includes a murder and subsequent execution steeped in irony.