While this show had been good to me for many years, and would make a good show to marathon on Netflix, this show is simply trash police propaganda, as with all other shows such as this. I will never watch this show, or any show like this, again. While at one time it was good to me and good for me, it's plainly propaganda for the police and other hands of government that I want no part of. That negates anything else this show has to offer. This belongs in the trash and in the past, as do the rest of the shows like this. Any cop show set in New York is inherently the worst given how terrible the real life NYPD. Add to that Islamophobic and other horrible elements.

I love CSI:NY, and yes I agree that it is better than CSI:Miami. For one thing it is stylishly photographed yes some of the more graphic images may disturb but I don't mind it so much. Secondly, it is brilliantly written, with intelligent dialogue and interesting episode ideas. Thirdly, the music is a real winner for me, the theme tune is very cool, then again it's the Who, what's not to like. Fourthly, the acting is very good, Gary Sinise is a great and I think underrated actor, and he is wonderful as Mac. Melina Kanakaredes looks stunning and acts convincingly which is a major plus in my book, and Carmine Giovinazzo is appealing as Danny. Overall, I love it. 10/10 Bethany Cox

I like the original a lot, CSI Miami lost it's appeal to me when Speedle died but CSI NY stays constantly appealing to me mostly due to the appeal of the characters. I've always been a huge fan of Gary Sinise and liked Eddie Cahill a lot in Friends but I'd honestly never heard of the other cast members.I'm surprised I haven't seen Carmine Giovinazzo in more things as he is an excellent actor and makes Danny Messer incredibly likable and appealing. Melina Kanakaredes' Stella Bonasera is also very likable and absolutely stunning. Adam I can only describe as cute and fairly geeky. As for Lindsay, although I can't say I like her a great deal I like what she has bought out in Danny's character.My only complaints are the loss of two great characters, Aiden and Detective Angell. I thought it was unnecessary especially to kill Angell as she was beginning to become a more frequently used character and it seems her death is an excuse for Don Flack to have a meltdown.I look forward to what season 6 brings. If it stays as good as the previous 5 I can only hope there are 6 more.

in my view,this entry in the CSI series is as good as CSI:Vegas.many of the episodes are pretty exciting.i also like the characters a lot.CSI:Vegas doesn't delve too much into the personal lives of its characters,whereas CSI:New York gives you some insight into them.plus,Gary Sinise is outstanding as the leader of the team,while i also like Melina Kanikaredes a lot.the show is much faster paced than either Vegas or Miami.each episode is exciting enough on its own that a cliffhanger episode isn't necessary at the end of the season.this approach is different from Vegas(Miami,i'm not to sure about,as i don't think i've watched a full season).i prefer this approach.that way,you don't have to deal with the unbearable suspense until the next season comes out.for me,CSI:NY is a 10/10