Smashing Pumpkins: If All Goes Wrong
Smashing Pumpkins: If All Goes Wrong
| 11 November 2008 (USA)
Smashing Pumpkins: If All Goes Wrong Trailers

A feature-length documentary about The Smashing Pumpkins, which chronicles the band's residencies at The Orange Peel in Asheville and The Fillmore in San Francisco in summer 2007. The documentary covers Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan's attempts to write and debut new music at the residencies, as well as the revival of the band with new members.

Reviews
rooprect

Bonus points to anyone who knows the 1976 song I quoted in my title. Here's an ironic hint: it was sung by a guy who threw a grand piano off the stage because he didn't like the light show.While Billy Corgan isn't quite as outwardly pianocidal, the overriding feeling throughout this behind-the-scenes tour journal is that Billy Corgan is extremely dissatisfied. You wouldn't think he has any right to be, with at least a dozen sellout shows full of rapturous fans, but somehow you get the vibe that he's not getting his rocks off."If All Goes Wrong" is a somewhat disenchanting documentary about the Pumpkins' 2007 mini tour which, rather than zipping all over the globe, planted itself in 2 locations: Asheville, NC and San Francisco, CA. The first thing that all Smashing Pumpkins fans should know is that none of their big hits are played. Correction, Billy sarcastically strums a few chords of (I think it was) "Today" with a painful grimace on his face in a hotel room before explaining that he doesn't want to associate with past members in any way.So what songs do they play? You're going to think I'm kidding but this is true. The bulk of the songs performed on this documentary were stream-of-consciousness diddies which Corgan wrote and hastily arranged for performance in front of an audience the very next day. At first it seemed impressive that he could pull it together like that, but after 6 or 7 repeats of the same formula (no exaggeration!) you get the feeling that Corgan is a lost soul. While the songs aren't quite as bad as "Chopping Broccoli" (look it up on Youtube if you haven't heard that masterpiece!), they are certainly unfinished, nothing like the meticulous arrangements and well-produced songs that filled the "Siamese Dream" years.Another major downer (don't worry, the good stuff is coming after) is that the band which Corgan had assembled for this tour are little more than hired guns. Corgan himself says this during one notable incident after a SF show when he lambasts his guitarist for acting like he's "in the band" when actually he's just an employee. Don't miss that scene toward the end as it really drives the point home. Other "employer review" moments include Corgan accusing his female bassist of boffing some guy outside his (Corgan's) hotel door while he was trying to sleep after the show. All this put together hammers the point home: The Smashing Pumpkins are not a band, this is not "sex drugs rock & roll", and nobody is really having a good time.OK, I promised you some good stuff, right? I actually enjoyed this documentary very much. It showed a side of the stereotypical jaded rockstar in a way we rarely see, warts and all. But unlike your standard rock'n'roll washup story about a rocker who can't reclaim his lost glory, this is a very different tragedy. The fans still love him, but Corgan is his own worst enemy, self destructive to the point that he insists on playing his 45-minute prog rock experiment which the band is clearly not prepared for, and the result is something like Spinal Tap's "Jazz Odyssey". All the same, I was enthralled at Corgan's total departure from sensibility. Yes, he could have played crowd pleasers, had a great time and made the fans happy. But no, instead he settled on the artistic merits of publicly self destructing (at one point ending a song with a bitter F U directed at the audience). And, no sarcasm here, I am intrigued by any visionary mind that would go so far to sabotage himself.Billy Corgan is a true wonder, I say with admiration. He comes across as a jerk, and yet if you go to his website you'll see many of his posts are about stray dogs & cats he's trying to get adopted. The songs played on this documentary were not particularly dazzling, but there were some absolute gems of lyrical wisdom if you listen to the words. Maybe you'll be as intrigued as I was when you watch this. Billy Corgan is not the kind of person I'd ever invite over to dinner (especially because he'd probably sock me in the gums after reading this review), but you can't deny he is an absolute original, a rebel against himself, and when you strip away all the loud guitars and screaming fans, isn't that what rock'n'roll is all about?

... View More
iliveinsin

'If it all goes wrong' is a well shot documentary that provides insight into the second incarnation of Smashing Pumpkins. Billy Corgan is revealed not to be the despot he is often to be, but rather a idealistic, workaholic songwriter dedicated to his craft. Likewise, Jimmy Chamberlin is revealed to be a central figure in the band, who at one point in the film, helps talk Billy down from his frustrations with the crowd. For those expecting a film about sex, drugs, and rock and roll - there is little of that. Gone are the days of the Smashing Pumpkins renown for the overdoses and members addicted to drugs. Billy Corgan tells the audience on one night that the first thing he was asked when he arrived at the 'orange peel' was if he wanted some weed, which he politely declined. It becomes apparent that Smashing Pumpkins is not about making money for Billy Corgan. He at one points admits that the residency was always going to be a loss. Jimmy Chamberlin and Billy Corgan are sticking true to the concept of what 'alternative music' was all about in the 90s - they aren't going to let themselves turn in a band touring on their 'greatest hits'. Probably the most interesting documentary about a band since 'Metallica: Some Kind of Monsters'.

... View More
ZombieFlanders

While it's not really something you would watch over and over, this documentary - which follows the newly reformed Pumpkins on a series of two residencies in Chicago and San Francisco in 2007 - is a highly watch able account and insight into the mind of one Billy Corgan, the man behind the Pumpkins and indeed, it's heart and soul.Rest assured, this is an interesting piece even for non-fans, but don't expect a big classic band reunion or a even classic songs showcase here as there is very little besides conversations regarding such times. But this is not the film's intention after all and it's far more watch able because of it. We talk with Billy (of course), current members (only), fans and few a managers and PA's along the way in-between this awkward time when the band is relishing the opportunity to grow as artists with a fresh attitude, but also dealing with what it means to the world and it's fans when you say a band like the Pumpkins is active again.A must see for old and new fans - or anyone just interested in songwriting for that matter - this will, at the very least, give you insight into Corgan for the better or make you dislike him even more. For fans, however, the inclusion of many songs written and performed acoustic when the film was made are shown with much affection. Love or loathe though, he is one artist that can't be ignored, and this film deserves not to be either.

... View More