Jesus Christ! This film is bad. I would have given one star but gave three for its moral goal - that being to turn people away from the antiquated christian belief structure which is but one of the global religions that continue to subjugated the poorest, ergo uneducated, humans on the planet.If any wavering christian watched this pseudo-saccharine slop they would quickly be freed of their mental slavery & thank goodness for that.Think about it; having had a well educated, hard working, ergo mentally stimulating & financially rewarding life with a hot full-lipped vamp temptress in your bed you suddenly wake to a thin-lipped uptight judgmental ball & chain & 2 bratty kids - hell's bells! You'd be mortified. I know which life I'd pick. Then again, one of his imaginary daughters did have big bosoms so there's an upside to every dog's dinner.

I have seen What If... many times and with each time I watch it, I love it more and more. It is an All Star Cast with perfection in acting. What If... is the perfect blend of joy, laughter and tears with a wonderful,unforgettable ending! What If... is going to be a timeless classic and is suitable for all ages. There is a message that is woven into the script that God loves each of us and that He has a purpose for our lives. I have a background in media and from a technical standpoint, the lighting, the camera and the directing were excellent, no details were missed. We need more movies like What If... with excellent values. Values that bring people together, values that give a deeper meaning to life. Excellent job Dallas! I look forward to watching it for years to come and I will keep watch for any other movies you produce...Matthew Shoemaker

I thought that this movie was a great throwback to how movies used to be. A modern day It's a Wonderful Life. It was very family friendly and contains many positive messages. For those who are looking for a thought provoking movie this one fits the bill. I saw it with my husband and teenage daughter and it gave us many meaningful conversations. The acting is top notch. We laughed and we cried often one right after the other. I haven't enjoyed an "angel" so much since Clarence. John Ratzenberger is fabulous. Taylor Groothuis who plays the younger daughter is delightful. Kevin Sorbo gives a very convincing performance as the corporate shark and as the man out of his element. As a Christian I was pleased to see an accurate depiction of faith without it seeming cheesy or fake.

Family Entertainment. You know, the feel-good, wholesome, honest, "take your child to without risking embarrassment" entertainment that is becoming popular once again. Professional cast (who would think of John Ratzenberger as an angel). Tried and true plot (but then how many truly original story lines have you seen lately?). Humor without being a comedy. Serious without being overbearing. Nice without being sticky-sweet. Christian without being overbearing (disclosure, I am a Christian). No blood, gore, bad language, bare-bodies or other objectionable content.A solid presentation. Intellectual enough that you go home thinking about the plot, not the special effects or love scene. At the same time, not so complicated that your child cannot follow.Highly recommended.