The Scarlet Tunic strongest point is the quality of the photography particularly in the use of colour and light. The spectacular scenery of the Wessex and Dorset coast provides natural beauty but other scenes using light in a unique way are key to the film's overall effect. The setting in the army camp comes to life completely through the use of superb light and shadows. Another example is the dramatic use of the scarlet tunic itself. The scene with the bright red garment lying on the beach creates a vivid and heart rendering moment. The story is one of a tragic romance, which is made even stronger by the quality of the visuals. Some of the acting is excellent with the two lead characters strong. My only negative feeling about this film was some of the characters are over acted and tend to distract from the overall quality of the film with the most objectionable being the Army captain.

Being very familiar with the area in which the film was shot, we empathised immediately with the settings. Having also had military connections the period uniforms interested us and we scrutinised every detail we could!(The position of the double V ranking stripes - which were ripped off, seemed to change position on the sleeve from time to time.) Firstly we enjoyed the movie enormously, even though neither of us had heard of the novel. The big names surprised us for such a modest production. The feeling of the pace of life was perfectly conveyed along with the simplicity of love and death in those times. Timing and opportunities were snatched at and acts of passion were colourfully acted out. The housekeeper and master relationship unfolded so naturally. The relationship which bore a love child girl, resulted in a family reunion at the end of the film - a relationship which the deceased hero and heroine had contrived to create. The film was a tragedy and it was in our opinion extremely well casted, the filming locations were of course perfect and authentic, costume and hair was good and the lighting we noticed brought the audience a little closer to actually being there. (Lighting is not something we comment on usually!) Make up was good as it should not have been visible in this piece, for this period or for these country folk. The death scene was "short lived"! It all happened so fast, which was a pity - more could have been made of this scene. But it was true love I guess. Thought there wasn't enough anger in this scene by the father.Believe it was a well budgeted film, and looking at the credits used local help too. More please.

Even actors as talented as Emma Fielding and Simon Callow could not save this one. These actors will put this one behind them and go on to greater accomplishments. I am impressed that they chose art over commercialism in this effort, and most especially with their faith in the material. But it was clear that the direction and editing left a great deal to be desired. My sense is that the best part of this effort was probably left on the cutting-room floor. One disappointing film does not break a career.

I just recently viewed this movie and found it to be a pleasant experience. The scenery was wonderfully photographed, and I got caught up in the title character's tragic romance.It was based on a Thomas Hardy novel and I felt that it truly captured the spirit of the book.