The Centaurs (1921)This Winsor McCay short is certainly worth watching if you're a fan of his work but sadly it's only available in fragments as some of the footage has been lost over time. What we basically have are some examples of a centaurs family (half human, half horse creatures) as they walk around in the woods. Again, since the film is incomplete it's hard to know exactly what McCay was going for but there's enough footage here to at least get a good idea of what the animation was like. I thought all of the creatures looked extremely good and I thought McCay did a nice job with the style of their bodies and how the human aspect of them were added in. I also thought the background work was pretty impressive and especially early on when we see one of the creatures walking through the woods. With that said, the one thing I thought was lacking was the quality of bringing the creatures to life and making you feel as if they're real. This is something shown in McCay's earlier work but it is missing here.

I saw three versions of this on YouTube (as linked from Google Video). One of them had a heavy metal score that seemed WAY unsuitable. Beautiful images of the forest and the half human-half horse figures that still makes one take his/her breath away some 86 years later. Would be nice to see if any other fragments have survived of this most fascinating film from the father of animation, Winsor McCay. As it is, it's still interesting to watch a young centaur couple try to get the approval of the older one and then have have a young boy who says "thank you" at the end. And thank you, Mr. McCay for all your contributions to the art of animation.

Winsor McCay was a newspaper cartoonist in the glorious days when cartoonists were given an entire over-sized Sunday newspaper page on which to give their artwork free rein. His full-colour comic-strip art is so remarkable that McCay's original newspaper pages (if you can find them) command high prices at modern art auctions. McCay eventually branched out into film animation, claiming to be the first artist to create moving drawings ... a claim that would come as a surprise to Émile Cohl and J. Stuart Blackton, both of whom preceded him.Although McCay was a prolific print artist, he made very few animated films. This was largely because McCay drew all the frames himself, without the help of 'in-betweeners'. For McCay's earliest cartoons (including the legendary 'Gertie the Dinosaur'), he drew the background and characters in each frame as a single drawing on paper: a time-consuming technique which required McCay to re-draw the entire background in each frame, even when it remained unchanged. By the time he began 'The Centaurs', McCay was using acetate cels to avoid this necessity.Like some other McCay animations, 'The Centaurs' was a project that he never finished: the existing footage is almost certainly all that was ever completed. There is no plot here: McCay depicts a youthful adult pair of centaurs chaperoned by an older pair of centaurs, apparently the young she-centaur's parents. The relationship between the young couple is unclear: they appear to be courting, yet we also encounter a pesky boy-centaur who is apparently their child. Or is this brat the she-centaur's kid brother?These centaurs gambol in an idyllic forest background which McCay draws very realistically. That's actually a drawback, no pun intended: I think that this footage would have looked far more interesting -- and McCay certainly could have completed it much faster -- if the centaur drawings on acetate cels had been superimposed against photographs of actual forest scenery.I am deeply impressed with much of McCay's work, but 'The Centaurs' -- such as it is -- is hardly McCay at his best. We get none of those breathtaking perspectives which McCay used elsewhere. The animation of the centaur figures is not convincing: their equine portions don't move like real horses, and their human portions move only slightly more realistically. It's a shame that McCay didn't have access to a rotoscope. Admittedly, centaurs are very implausible creatures anyway: a horse reaches maturity much sooner than a human, so the lower end of the boy-centaur should be an adult already.'The Centaurs' was a strange project for McCay to have undertaken. Centaurs are lusty, sensual creatures, yet McCay has chosen to bowdlerise his figures. The she-centaur's breasts are only briefly suggested, and have no nipples. The males have no nipples either, and the crop of the he-centaur is not seen. If McCay was too much of a prude to give his centaurs sexual characteristics (or if he was drawing for an audience who felt that way), then why did he choose this particular theme?The older she-centaur (the sour-faced chaperone) wears pince-nez spectacles, leaving us to wonder if centaurs have access to opticians. At one point, the virile centaur shies a stone at a bird, bringing a bit of male violence to this idyl. Perhaps 'The Centaurs' might have been more impressive if McCay had completed it, but I doubt that this is the case. All of McCay's animation is impressive, but 'The Centaurs' is not the best introduction to his work. I'll rate this only 5 out of 10.Sadly, almost none of McCay's original artwork survives. In 1982, I interviewed American comic-book artist Leonard B Cole, who worked alongside artist Robert McCay (Winsor's son) in the 1940s. Cole told me that McCay once brought a large quantity of his father's artwork to the studio where they worked, and offered to give it away to any artist who would take it. There were no takers, so McCay simply threw out the lot! (Cole, needless to say, long since regretted his refusal of the offer.) Today, those illustration boards would be priceless. Got a time machine handy?

Only a small part of this cartoon survive, about a minute and a half of lovely images by the foremost cartoonist of the the early 20th century. Several of Windsor McCay's cartoons are considered classics of the art, such as GERTIE THE DINOSAUR and THE SINKING OF THE LUSITANIA, but the draftsmanship and execution of these remnants make it, along with the Fleischer Superman cartoons, make it the most beautiful animation in the history of the art.