Stephen and Timothy Quay made quite a few animated shorts, but most of them were much longer than this. In fact, this is no doubt their shortest film. There is not that much to it. It's barely a minute long, and another reviewer said that was too short. Well, actually, I think that might be all the better, to leave the viewer hanging like that. It really doesn't need anymore.The film is very incoherent, and it was meant to be. It consists of a magnet spinning in place, and an animated puppet (which is a little creepy-looking) watching. It's a very simple set-up, yet is quite nightmarish. The Quay Bros made a series of Stille Nacht short films and this is the first. The others I'll definitely have to look at. Their other films are probably better in some regards, but this is an interesting diversion. If you're a fan of these surrealist art shorts like I am, then this little movie will meet your fancy.

"Stille Nacht I" is an American (very) short movie with a runtime of only one minute. It is black-and-white and was shot by the Quay Twins (among America's most famous animators in the first half of the 20th century) as the first of so far five entries to their "Silent Night" short film series. We see creepy dolls, spoons and just feel a general aura of discomfort. The creepy music certainly helps the overall picture. However, I was not scared once and this should usually be the goal of a horror film. It was just strange and weird somehow. All in all, I would not recommend this and I really hope that the next entries to this series will be superior to this forgettable one here.

This is the kind of short that I could see several times, and it never fails to impress me: In only a minute, and without any dialogue, this fascinating short directed by the Quay Brothers ("Street of Crocodiles") has not only a wonderful, dream-like atmosphere and a magnificent visual style, but also posses a unique sense of beauty and lyricism that is hard to find in any other kind of film, even in those movies that try to hard to be "poetical" and "subjetive".However, this manages to work incredibly well, turning the whimsical qualities of the dreams into stop-motion animation. I think that if this short were made in live-action, it just won't have the same effect.

This short is utterly delightful. There's not much to it in terms of what is available to be seen and commented on, but there is a lot to it in terms of what was done and how. Instead of flecking their sets with dust and hair, the brothers Quay place a magnet in a field and let the magnet play with all the little magnetic fragments. It's creepy... but it's fun! I honestly don't know what to make of the babydoll that watches the whole thing, eventually to turn and attempt to eat a meal, but it doesn't make me want to eat anything anytime soon! I think this is more something the brothers have done in order to experiment with something they haven't yet put into a longer film, but wanted to do regardless.--PolarisDiB