Hrithik Roshan early in his career proved that KNPH was not a fluke..Awesome performance...Movie tells a story of how messy is Kashmir issue and best part of the movie is the cinematography .. Music is superb too.Performance-Sanjay Dutts best role till date after Vaastav..Preity Zinta was good too .But the man himself Hrithik Roshan is simply brilliant.The movie released at a time were Dulhan hum Le Jayenge ,Kuch Kuch Hota Hai ,Mohabbatein were the genre that people preferred ,but this movie remains superb in comparison to even to days 200 Cr films..Highly recommended..

Plot potential = 8 Plot execution = 1? 0? Massively unrealistic ending - plot and character development - non-existent and it's the first Bollywood/Hindi movie I've ever seen when I fast-forwarded through all but one of the songs. Did I mention an ending that is completely unrealistic, unnatural, wrong in so many ways and totally unrealistic?Pass on this. No, really, pass - it's horrible. I was at least hoping for some decent shots of Kashmir and the culture, etc... Nope. Not even that.I greatly appreciated the intent of the film from the tribute page at the end, but this film is no tribute to anything except bad film making and bad acting - even from good/great actors. Rent Yaadein if you want to see a great film w/ Jackie Shroff and Hrithik Roshan. And Sonali Kulkarni, while in a supporting role, is great in Dil Chahta Hai as is Preity Zinta.

English Audio dubbing has been made available on the DVDs that can now be rented at Hollywood Video & Blockbuster.The dubbing is flawless! And I think the movie is a true neutral view of the Kashmir Situation.Good job!

From a 30,000ft level, the story was great, but coming down to minute details, the movie came a bit short. It was jerky at times and some songs/events seemed to appear out of nowhere. Music was great and Vidhu Vinod Chopra's direction was superb.