The music and musical numbers are the real highlights of Mary Poppins, which is as it should be considering it is a movie musical. Its the remainder of the film that disappoints. Julie Andrews sings beautifully and sounds effortless in her musical executions, but while she does play a 'prim and proper' nanny I think her performance feels emotionless and a rather cold. The children are played very flat and one dimensional and don't bring the childlike energy and exuberance the roles require. I also found the film a bit long considering the material it had to work with. I do think Mary Poppins is worth checking out but I don't share the same enthusiasm that so many others feel for this film.

Timeless songs and endless optimism make this unforgettable! "Chim Chim Cher-Ee" is truly haunting and dark, yet still as catchy as today's pop singles can only hope to be! Great family fun.

This is one of my childhood favorites. I couldn't handle many long movies but 139 minutes of this was perfect for me! I have so many memories with this movie. Learned to pronounce the above word, wetting my pants once and having to take out the tape as punishment, ripping the cover off for no reason, learning that the mother says "stupid" in her song, and much more. Even at age 19 I still love it! Do not deprive your kids of this excellent classic! If they are not into live action yet then wait a couple years, but there is some animation in the chalk drawing scene.

Christmas is a time when the TV channels normally wheel out classic family movies, and this Boxing Day I caught "Mary Poppins", one of my favourite films as a child, but one which I had not seen for many years. The story is set in the London of 1910. Mary Poppins, a mysterious, magical figure blown in with the wind, takes a job as nanny to Jane and Michael, the children of George Banks, a well-to-do banker. Mr Banks hopes that Mary will reform his occasionally unruly children's behaviour, but it soon becomes clear that it is really their parents who need reforming. George, a stern Edwardian paterfamilias, pays more attention to his work than he does to his family, and his wife Winifred is too preoccupied with political good causes to have much time for her children. This was the film which Walt Disney tried to make for over twenty years. In the 1930s he had promised his young daughters that he would make a film of their favourite "Mary Poppins" books. For a long time, however, it appeared that Disney would be unable to fulfil his promise. The main obstacle was the author of the books, Pamela Travers, who disliked the idea of her books being filmed, especially by Disney whom she considered a vulgar showman; when she finally relented in 1961 it is said that she was prompted more by financial difficulties than by a genuine change of heart. The story of Disney's battle with Travers is told in the recent "Saving Mr Banks". I have not read Travers' books since my childhood, but I recall that her Mary was a rather strict middle-aged figure. Here she is played by Julie Andrews as young, beautiful, gentle and kind-hearted. Now it is a truth universally acknowledged in Hollywood, that a single woman in possession of youth, beauty, gentleness and a kind heart, must be in want of a husband, or at least a boyfriend. Universally acknowledged, that is, by everyone except Pamela Travers. Disney wanted to introduce a romance between Mary and Bert, the Cockney jack-of-all-trades played by Dick Van Dyke, but Travers resolutely vetoed this, so their relationship had to remain platonic. Two battles Travers fought and lost were over the Sherman Brothers' songs, which she disliked, and over the use of animation, which she loathed. (She was even badgering Disney to remove them during the party after the premiere; he replied laconically "Pamela, that ship has sailed", and walked away). I think we can be glad that she lost these battles. The musical score- cheerful, lively, witty and bursting with great tunes- is one of the film's best features; every time we saw it my sisters and I would be singing "Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious", "Feed the Birds" and "Chim-Chim-Cher-ee" for days. The Sherman Brothers, in fact, threw themselves energetically into their song-writing duties; they produced more than 30 original songs for the movie, most of which were never used. As for the animated sequences, they emphasise the fantastical, magical nature of the story, making it something more than just a mundane tale of London in the olden days. This is the film which made Julie Andrews, previously a well-known Broadway actress, into a huge international star. Her "Best Actress" Oscar must have been the most welcome form of consolation after her disappointment at being (controversially) passed over in favour of Audrey Hepburn for the role of Eliza in "My Fair Lady", a role which Andrews had created on Broadway. (The film as a whole was nominated for "Best Picture", the only such nomination Disney received in his lifetime). There are some good supporting performances, especially from David Tomlinson as George Banks, a man who beneath an outward mask of pomposity and severity is not quite the domestic tyrant he has always seemed. The weak link in the acting has traditionally been said to be Van Dyke, and this is one battle which I wished Travers had won. She wanted a British actor in the role, but Disney insisted on having someone familiar to American audiences. Van Dyke is good when it comes to dancing and general clowning around, but his attempt to sound like a Cockney has gone down in history as one of the worst cinema accents ever. Van Dyke could, in fact, do an acceptable British RP accent, as he shows in his cameo role as George's boss Old Mr Dawes, but our working-class and regional accents are notoriously difficult for American actors to imitate. Even Meryl Streep, Hollywood's resident dialect specialist, shied away from a West Country accent in "The French Lieutenant's Woman". The need to break the action occasionally so that people can break into song means that musicals generally take longer to tell their stories than "straight" films, and "Mary Poppins" is no exception. (Just think how lengthy it might have been had all those 30-odd songs made the final cut). The action does tend to flag in a few places; I felt that the "Uncle Albert" sequences went on a bit too long, both as a child and as an adult. Overall, however, it has stood the test of time well, and will doubtless entertain modern children as well as it did my generation. 8/10Some goofs. The robins we see "feathering their nest" are American Robins, a species not found in Britain. The European Robin, although it also has a red breast, is only distantly related to its American namesake. Also, there are no freshwater turtles in Britain.