I don't think it was bad, Definitely not attend but didn't deserve as low as it got

PROS: There are shreds of moments when the acting is good, but those moments are far and in between. Overall, there is simply just no pros.CONS: No fear, no purpose. There was no tension built up in the film at all. The opening scene and the end scene are the only times when the director even bothered to add some fear. That's it. For about an hour you are kept sitting in front of a screen absolutely clueless to what is happening. The plot is so magnificently pointless as well. I'll try explain, but it's going to be hard. A girl who is supposedly supposed to have a twin gets tortured until the twin gets hurt??? The connections made between characters in this film are quite simply non existent. All depth that characters are supposed to have has vanished, because each and every person in the story added no relevance to the film, and no detail or substance to the plot. Which yet again is a reason the movie failed. The final thing is the ending. Like what! How could anyone think this film was good with an ending like that. The resolution is so worthless to the story that it might as well not even be there.www.chorror.com

I've been meaning to write this for a long time, but the reviews of this movie are largely unfair. I found this movie a deliciously dark, often witty but scary experience. The writing is quite good, miles ahead of what the genre usually provides. Character work was detailed and dialogue was way above average. Somehow I think that Lindsey Lohan's reputation at the time was reviewed more than the movie, which is miles ahead of most films in this genre. The dual personalities and the theme of separating reality from fantasy is very well positioned in the script, which brings a level of thematic to the piece that's rare for the genre, as well. I also think the movie, because it was sold as a horror film, was hugely misunderstood.

I just don't get all the hatred this movie has. It is disturbing, creepy, unpredictable (to me at least it was) and Lohan acts well, all good things for a good thriller. Not only entertaining, the shots are nice, the music is eerie and there are so many elements to it that make me want to watch it again and again. Would it have been a better film without Lindsay Lohan in it? Probably, but that's just because it would make it less predictable for those who couldn't suspend disbelief while watching the movie. Some of the scenes are hard to watch, Black Swan style, other's reminded me of Mulholland Drive. If you're looking for a run-of-the-mill (even a B) horror movie or seeing Lindsay Lohan get naked, move along. This is more of a surreal suspensy quirky awesome little gem that apparently few can appreciate. Why? Beats the hell out of me.