I am not sure why there are so much negative comment.The story is backed by really strong script and some really good acting from all the stars, even from Emraan Hashmi. I decided to watch the movie purely because the music was absolutely amazing. I was not expecting much from it but was pleasantly surprised. Mind you that I am not easily impressed by bollywood movies but this was definitely an exception

Why Vidya why?? what made you choose Hamaari Adhuri Kahani..... This movie tries to show how intense love can be...n goes over the top....the dialogues are ridiculously insane.....n at times turn hilarious....god damn!!! who speaks that way!!! HAK lacks logic....its saturated with melodrama....its sad....over the top emotional....the film has a decent story-line but,it needed to be executed well!!! the meaningless dialogues n logic-less screenplay eat the essence of the story .....This Mohit Suri movie doesn't quite hit the right note....I think he just wanted to prove that Aashiqui2 n Ek villain were better movies....talented actors were totally wasted in this movie......The only good thing about this movie apart from the songs was......well! ...The End!!!!....

A friend recommended this film so I bought the CD. Watched it yesterday.Mediocre is the best overall description.This is a typical Mohabbat ki Junoon love story, not very well enacted at that. The plot is not strong enough and tends to drag. The film became somewhat interesting only from the second half but even that was not deserving of anything other than the mediocre tag.Sorry to say and I have nothing against him otherwise, but Emran Hashmi was sickening in his role. He just could not pull it off. Vidya Balan was okay but what could she do with a story like this? Rajkumar Rao acted fairly well, but again the plot put it all to vain.Several other minor flaws such as the valley of flowers scene incongruously stuck in the midst of the Bastar jungles, did nothing to help the overall lackadaisical plot. Not sure why they bothered to film at Qasr Al Sarab in the Rub Al Khali desert. It did nothing to help the movie, other than to perhaps attract a few viewers from the UAE!Watch this on TV if you must, and if you can sit through the entire film.

Being an avid English movie viewer, I was rather a pessimist to watch this movie.What started out as a lazy couch potato movie turned out to be one of the most loved movies by me. I never expected that love could be shown in such beautiful ways.The manner in which the male protagonist has portrayed the emotions and the feel of it is unexplainable. The way in which the director has captured the essence of emotions is truly remarkable.I would truly recommend this movie a watch.If you really want to fall in love again this is the movie you should watch.Vidya does a fantastic job with her portrayal of sadness and love. i could relate to the pain in Emran's eyes.It was too good to be true.