This movie had potential but fails to make an impression. Vidya Balan and Rajkumar Rao were as usual stupendous in the scenes involving them, those were the only moments which perhaps had an impact on the viewer, otherwise average stereotype acting by Hashmi and a porous script damages the prospect for this movie, what could have been a soulful romantic tragedy. Emraan has still a long way to go as an actor and just could not match up to the lead woman in the movie. The way it ended, should have moistened the eyes of an average chick-flick lover, but it certainly even failed on that count. I can't go with more than 5/10 for this one...

This movie reminds me of the Hollywood movie "the bridges of Madison county", though the stories are totally different but there is some emotional connection between the two. It has got brilliant story, mind blowing acting by Vidya Balen, Imran hashmi and not the least Raj kumar. Songs are amazing and fully connected with the movie. And finally, now onwards I am fan of Vidya Balen.

In the era where all the movie rotate around stunts and stupid songs,A different movie which shows what really LOVE IS.After a long time i felt something in my heart feeling love inside most of them wont like this movie as they are addicted to the stunts,sexy songs,stupid jokes and crazy things.This movie focuses on LOVE and Mercy to others...Should watch one time. I liked the song Hasi and the Title song.Story is between the rituals and love.Plot: Five years after the mysterious disappearance of her husband, a woman becomes romantically involved with a wealthy hotelier and together they confront her past.Though there are some errors but ignorable.

Mohit Suri's 'Hamari Adhuri Kahaani' is An Inconsistent, Yet Watchable Tragic Love-Story! Its brooding with sadness & although its never entirely convincing, this story still has a few moments, that evoke a certain emotion within you. Its flawed, but not without its pluses!'Hamari Adhuri Kahaani' Synopsis: Five years after the mysterious disappearance of her husband, a woman becomes romantically involved with a wealthy hotelier and together they confront her past.'Hamari Adhuri Kahaani' is a tragedy & hence the film mostly deals with the downs of life. The main characters are finely written, but they are so sad beneath, that after a point, you're exhausted. No, this isn't a depressing story, but at its heart, its an incomplete love saga about 2 people who just can't be one.Mahesh Bhatt & Shagufta Rafiq's Screenplay is impressive in parts, but lags otherwise. While the first-hour moves a slow-pace, the second-hour slips into full on tragedy mode. However, the final act is unconvincing. The culmination, especially, doesn't work. The Writing isn't bad, but it could've been stronger & more convincing. Mohit Suri's Direction is decent. Cinematography is alright. Editing is loose at times. Mithoon, Jeet Ganguly & Ami Mishra's Songs are wonderful. Raju Singh's Background Score is excellent, as well.Performance-Wise: Vidya Balan is earnest in her portrayal of a women torn between a broken marriage & a relationship she can't accept due to her morales. Though her character is regressive, Balan makes her believable, despite the Script's loopholes. Emraan Hashmi is brilliant & also the scene-stealer. He is mature, subdued & absolutely perfect as the sympathetic hero. Rajkumar Rao has a small role, but he leaves a mark as the hard-to-love husband. Namit Das is passable. Prabal Panjabi & Narendra Jha are adequate. Suhasini Mulay is terrific a cameo.On the whole, 'Hamari Adhuri Kahaani' is a so-so fare.